I was born into the system. I didn't choose it, it was my birthright. Perhaps, for that reason, I failed to see the beauty of it. Because there
is beauty, of that I am certain, but it is covered, hidden, and I have yet to discover it.
The system, roughly, goes like this. You are born into a Lubavitch family. Your parents may have been Baal Tshuva, or Frum from birth, with many generations of lineage to prove it. BT or FFB in short, which basically gives some people an excuse to say 'I'm better than you', when in no way are they better.
You grow up in a Lubavitch community, in this case I'll use Crown Heights, as an example, because thats where I grew up, and where 'the system' is most dominent.
You go to Bais Rivkah or Ohlei Torah all your life. Now you are no longer a person, but a number. One in a grade of 130, one in a school of over 1000. You don't have a chance to prove yourself, or expand your talents, or assert your individuality. In a school of over 2000, individuality is not possible. The girls who are the loudest get heard, while the quiet ones fall to the wayside, lost, forgotten about, while they have so much to give, but no one to give it to.
The system has many rules. These are not official, of course. These are unwritten rules, things that are known, but never spoken about. It tells us how to dress. It tells us who to be friends with, how we should act, etc. These rules you want to follow, because you are trying to copy someone, some unknown person who makes these rules. But who are you really trying to impress?
It's like an exclusive club that I somehow did not get membership to. I walk into 770, and I feel like an outsider. Somehow the holyness of a shul, and 770 specifically, has gotten mixed up with a central meeting place, where you mingle, and chat with friends you havn't seen in a long time, or parade around in your new Shabbos outfit. It's like a runway. You walk in the door and heads swivel to look you up and down, from head to toe. In general this is wrong, but especially taking place in 770, the Rebbes shul, it hurts to see. So I don't go.
The system is strong in boys yeshivos too. They try to fit a square into a round hole. If it doesn't fit, they cut off the edges. So what if the boy will lose part of himself in the process, but at least he'll be a good bochur, just like everyone else, right?
Wrong. There is no one manual for children, for students. We are each born with different talents, different capabilities, different ways of thinking. We each have our own guidebook, our own separate paths in life. It is up to our teachers, leaders, and parents to tap into that, to help us discover who we are, and what we are capable of accomplishing.
But they forget that. There are so many of us, we get lumped together, all packaged with the same lable. Individuality is not encouraged, talents may not be expanded, and therefore, wasted.
Chabad is supposedly one big family. There are thousads of Chabad houses all over the world, opening their doors and hearts wide for strangers, caring, sharing, and being there for them. While here in the 'Shchuna', our own are getting lost, tramppled upon, neglected.
Where are the shluchim here? Who are we supposed to turn to in time of need?
When a boy 'frys out, G-d forbid, people point fingers, place blame, and put him down. He becomes an outcast. But where were these same people when this boy was crying out, pleading silently for someone to help him, and understand him? They weren't there. They ignored the warning signs, trying to convince themselves that all was fine. So in reality, they pushed him out the door with their own two hands.
In the system, shluchis is preached about. From the time when a child is young, they know what shluchis is, and that the ultimate goal is to become the Rebbes shliach, and help bring Moshiach. It is so ingrained in them, that we find our little mushkies and mendels playing shliach, or Rebbe and chossid, instead of the games of the goyishe velt.
A girl is encouraged to go on a year of shluchis after seminary, and a boy does shluchis as part of the smicha process. This is meant to be a taste of what will come, what they will face when they eventually get married, and go on shluchis.
And yet, I know of so many couples sitting in Crown Heights, waiting for over a year, only to get their hopes dashed, because no position is available. While perhaps other young couples, who have connections, will get a position right away. So why preach if you won't pull through in the end?
A girl who wants to go to college is practically considered not frum, in the eyes of many. And a boy who wants to learn a trade instead of getting smicha, or going on shluchis, is looked down upon. But are these boys and girls supposed to sit forever, wasting their life away, waiting for shlichus, when it may never happen?
The Rebbe spoke about shlichus constantly, and promised many brachos to those who go on shlichus. I love shluchim, and the concept of shlichus. It is an attitude, a way of life. The world needs shluchim, and there are so many out there who are B''H doing amazing work. But why does it seem like it turned into a competition? I used to dream of going on shlichus, now I'm a little less sure.
When the Frierdike Rebbe came to America, he chose Crown Heights to be his base. It became the main force behind all Chabad activities throughout the world. Lubavitch world headquarters, Bais Rabainu Shebibavel. It is a special place, a holy place, and we, the people of Crown Heights, should treat it as such. Is is an honor to be able to live the very neighborhood where the Rebbe walked.
So then why do I see such shmutz? I'm not talking about physically. Yes, New York is dirty, but it is mine, it's home. But why must I feel like a stranger in my own hometown?
I have friends who come from small towns, and they speak of their communities with such pride.
When someone asks me where I'm from, I'm almost embarrassed to say Crown Heights.
Firstly, because it's not 'my place'. It is everyones. Crown Heights is home to all of Chabad.
But thats not a problem, thats a special thing to be able to share your home with so many strangers.
But mostly because I feel like an outsider, like I don't belong. I walk down the street and I feel eyes on me, judging me. They judge me on my mode of dress, whether it's according to the current fashion trends, or if it's tznius enough. They wonder who I am, and if I'm a 'somebody', worth investing their time talking about. I make one move and everyone has something to say about it.
Sometimes I wish that I was born in a small quiet hicktown, where everyone knows everyone, and people are friendly and welcoming, and not so judgmental.
But then I remember that everywhere has its problems.
Then I wish that Crown Heights was different, that people were more accepting, and less gossipy.
Sometimes I wish that I was a Baal Tshuva, because they tend to see only the beauty, and not the shmutz. I wish I could be someone on the outside, looking in, cuz everything always looks much better from that vantage point. But I was born into 'The system'.
Whether I will go on shlichus or to college doesn't matter. If I go to college, I know people will talk, but let them, what they have to say doesn't bother me.
Whether I choose to live in Crown Heights after I get married, and send my little mushkie and mendel to Bais Rivkah and Ohlei Torah is not the point here.
What is important is that the system doesn't work. No one created this system, no one is in charge of this system, but it is there, nontheless.
Who should I blame for it, for the fact that I have no pride in where I come from? That I don't feel comfortable in my own home? That people are judgmental, and if you don't act a certain way, talk a certain way, or are friends with the wrong person, your considered a 'nobody'?
If it's true what they say, that 'Chassidim ain mishpacha', Chabad is one big family, then we have a problem here.
There is no point placing blame, for no one is responsible for the fact that Crown Heights, and Lubavitch,
became this way. But
everyone has a responsibility to help change it, to help break the system that we are stuck in.
People who are not Lubavitch have asked me countless times, why does Chabad think theyre better than us, and the rest of the world? And I have no answer for them, I don't know.
I don't doubt that Chassidus, and specifically Chabad Chassidus, is the truth, and that we will be at the front lines to greet Moshiach. I don't doubt that the Rebbe, our holy Rebbe, is the leader of all Jews worldwide, and that every holy word he says is the truth.
But I doubt that we are better than everyone else. Special, maybe. The prince, the son of the king, is special, yes. But only because of his title, his position. What makes him a better person are his actions, how he chooses to conduct himself. That is entirely up to him.
We are all Chassidim, whether we like it or not. The Rebbe chose us to be his Chassidim, and he gave us a mission, to bring Moshiach. He has faith in us that we will get the job done.
So why are we betraying his trust?
We are special, but we are not better. We have outreach, but we don't have inreach.
There are other Chassidic groups that are extra carefull with shmiras halashon, or Tznius. We laugh at them, how they dress closed up, or old fashioned. What right do we have to judge them, when we dress like the goyishe models of the velt?
Our mission is to bring Moshiach. We must reach for the stars, but don't forget the little things along the way. Moshiach includes all those other things, especially tznius.
Bringing moshiach is a big job, but all it takes is one small brick. Bit by bit we can do it. A 1/2 hour of your day thats lashon hara free. An extra button on your shirt thats closed. A smile and greeting to a passing stranger.
I look at the shluchim of the world, and I am envious of the special work they are doing. They are doing exactly what the Rebbe asked, and demanded of each and every one of us, spreading the Torah, teaching about moshiach, and bringing Jews closer to yidishkeit. They are the lamplighters of the world, and the Rebbe has promised countless brachos to shluchim, and spoke about them with such warmth. But I am not out there, I am here. What am I doing to help bring moshiach?
And then I realized, that every flame has a source, from where it gets its light. Here in Crown Heights, we are that source. As the headquarters, we have the job of keeping it all running. It all starts here, and spreads to the rest of the world.
Everyone looks at us, and talks about us, and points fingers at us. The job is that much harder now. But we
can do it, because the Rebbe believes in us.
I may not like Crown Heights, but I grew up here. I may not have pride in where I come from, but it is a part of me. You can take someone out of Crown Heights, but you can't take Crown Heights out of them. I may leave, but I'll always come back. I may not see the beauty now, but maybe one day I'll see it.
We all have a job to do. I think I'm doing mine. I am breaking the system.